The issue and preferred resolution, in GetHuman601310's own words:
Log in ... After resetting my p***word it wanted me to verify a phone number that was not mine and i did not recognize, the only option was to send the code but i did not want to send a code to a phone number i do not know
I trust that Venmo will make this right and come up with a resolution that is fair.
Help with my Venmo issue
Follow this to see how it gets fixed
Find similar issues & what fixed it
Follow 3 or more issues like yours to increase the chances that another customer helps you find the right answer.